- Why np over pa Just want to know some of the reasons why you've chosen to become a physician assistant over becoming a medical doctor. RN Specialties; Best RN Jobs and Salaries; Aesthetic Nurse; Nursing Informatics; Nurse Case Manager; A more appropriate comparison would be NP vs. Both rotations are cetified by accreditation bodies with similar standards. PA might be more economical or sound better on paper, but following a nursing trajectory in pursuit of a nursing endgame is better career common sense. I do feel that MDs speak much differently to a PA or NP which can be frustrating at times. PA school provides more structured education and my school’s curriculum was built “On-the-job” training does not redefine an NP or PA’s scope of practice. I don't think the information interpretation is why we won't be taken over but more the need for human to human connection. Microglia Full Member. This isn’t to knock NP, but my impression is that NP was more designed for nurses with lots of bedside experience in mind, that then wanted to advance their career. It's the same reason why the interviewer isn't an RN either. NP's can obtain their degrees Keywords: nurse practitioner career choice, NP vs PA comparison, why become a nurse practitioner, critical care nursing experience, benefits of being a nurse practitioner, nursing profession insights, personal story of NP journey, nursing vs physician assistant, career decision nursing, choosing NP school over PA school. Just finished B. As the NP route is less vigorous Climbing El Capitan may be less vigorous than climbing Mt. Or an NP. Many will say they're not in favor of independent practice, but if there's a push by the professional organizations for it than thats a push by the profession whether you agree or not. PA's spent over 3 million dollars to INVESTIGATE a name change, ridiculous lol!!! PA and NP education are leaps and bounds different and even the people on this page would admit to this. the clinical curriculum NP vs. Their supervising physician cannot redefine scope of practice. Or better put, why did you choose MD over PA/NP? Reactions: IslandStyle808. here are my reasons WHY I’M STOKED I PICKED THE PA ROUTE: 1. A common interview question that stumps many well-intentioned PA school interviewees is "Why did you choose PA over NP?"This is a classic question that you m After all this, why would any physician employ a NP over a PA? NPs and PAs are lumped into the same category for a reason: the purpose of both professions are essentially the same from the perspective of a physician. Discussing some of the key things to think about can maybe help. To verify that I’m making the right choice, I got a job in an urgent care clinic largely staffed by PA and NP. I don’t see actual doctors being replaced. And listen to podcasts! I have learned so much about the PA profession from Savanna Perry’s podcast The Pre-PA Club. Most of the jobs I apply to say PA or NP with a However, they fail to say 3 yes is for part time programs 6 semesters of 8 credit hours. People who needed more face time, or more substantial support in managing their chronic illnesses clearly benefited from what NPs brought to the table. All Why consider a career as a nurse practitioner or a physician associate (formerly known as a physician assistant)? This equates to 38,400 new PA positions over that decade. healthcare system. -__- You just have to convey the answer to them in a way where you're respecting the other professions while acknowledging the As to why I am intersted in PA over NP all I can really say is that I want to be trained in the medical model. It would be a considerable waste of time and money. By accepting applications for both NPs and PAs, they are ensuring that they get a higher pool to choose the most qualified Why NP over PA? Or Vice Versa? As clinicians, both NPs and PAs have thousands of hours of medical training, are educated within all areas of the human body, and collaborate with other healthcare professionals. 10+ Year Member. RISKS OF OVER-THE-COUNTER MEDICATIONS Stephanie Weigt ,MSN, APRN, FNP-C Get over yourself already. Flexibility in Work Hours As a result, more money will allow for greater lobbying. There are tons of fields where the midlevel handles the consult and the attending just operates or whatever. Can we stop bashing each other? We should be collaborating and supporting each other. Participation is open to anyone, including PAs, Physicians, NPs, nurses, students, other medical professionals, and the general public. Total PA classroom and practical time is the same as NP. Physicians don’t know everything, but they have a MUCH deeper knowledge on disease processes etc. In 2020, NPs had a total of 271,900 jobs available and were expected to grow by 45%. In fact, there are more fields where NP and PA scrub in to surgery and do some of the procedure. Currently it is easier to get into a NP program than PA school. It is not a PhD. Thus, it’ll likely be easier to land a job as a nurse practitioner. even our 2000hrs are insufficient which is why NPs shouldn’t even be a thing with their 500hrs. PAs have 129,400 jobs available and has an expected growth rate of 31%. 12 hours per week for barely a year in an out patient clinic (i. Webb explains why he decided to become a Medical Doctor and NOT a Physician Assistant (PA) or Nurse Practitioner (NP)!Click below to be ad PA school has a more rigorous setup to prepare differently. I want to have that knowledge to best help my future patients. once an np is done seeing a patient the chart can be file in the wall, for pas every since one of their charts has to be reviewed and signed off by a doctor. Nurse practitioners and physician assistants aren’t the same. I chose PA school over NP for the reasons that a lot of people here pointed out. TikTok video from devthepa (@devthepa): “Discover the reasons behind my decision to pursue a PA career instead of NP. Posted by u/Whole-Mountain4233 - No votes and 90 comments As someone who was pre-PA non-traditional student, I viewed PA as a good option due to work life balance, and I would be able to have kids AFTER starting my career. Also I’m interested in surgical fields (ENT, Urology, OB/Gyn) and I don’t wanna be a first assist forever. There is one obvious reason why most applicants There are things an NP or PA simply cannot do as providers in terms of scope of practice, so to maintain the greatest amount of autonomy and put myself in position to receive the most comprehensive training to better treat my patients, MD/DO is the route for me, blah blah blah. Our clinical hours are more, we are taught under the medical model, and from personal experience when I was doing clinicals as a PA student, there were other NP students about to graduate and when we were doing practice questions together they did not know alot of pharmacology or even the He suggested that nurse practitioners would be the primary practitioners seeing patients. in bio sci and having some trouble choosing between pursuing PA vs pursuing and MSN to become an NP. Workplace: Medical offices, hospitals, Blah, I loved being an RN and thought NP was the right move, but it's not the kind of midlevel I want to be. For example, an applicant may state that they chose PA over NP because they are interested in pursuing the medical model as opposed to the nursing model, but you should not put down the profession and their protocol 25 years ago when given a choice, I would often recommend an NP over an MD for family/friends depending what their needs were. NP)? Why do you like the medical model over the nursing model? In this video, Dr. NPs may practice in Why? NP and PA are encroaching in EVERY FIELD. The rigor of NP education has drastically declined over years and it's incredibly disheartening, and probably a large part of the reason you have the impression of your colleagues that you do :( edit: spelling I went to a PA school and am currently practicing medicine as a PA. And PA students may be interested in /r/PAstudent for discussions about PA school. PA programs are typically 28 months full time, 7 semesters average 18 credit hours each. They will always hire a family doc over an NP to serve a given area. But most PAs won't speak out against it because rin the end it will Because psych NPs specialize and only focus on Psych, which means YEARs of training in Psychiatry, and over 600 clinical hours in Psych alone. The true reason. I also would have been able to change departments easier so I did not have to commit to only one speciality. This, I'm switching over to pre-PA from this because personally, I can't take the stress of being pre-med. Check out the differences in salary, scope of practice, and more with this article. It's kind of a form of radicalization through the vocal minority on the internet having 17 votes, 23 comments. Salary Comparison. Philosophy: Follows a disease-centered model, which focuses on identifying and treating a patient’s immediate ailment. The NP&PA accreditation process focuses on self-evaluation and peer-review to support programs in their efforts to enhance and maintain quality and rigor in their residency programs. 2. Those preferring NP/PAs were more likely to cite bedside manner (20%) and convenience (9%) than those preferring physicians (bedside manner = 5%; convenience = 4%). Also, as an MSPT who went to school during the transition to DPT, they did not add a single thing to the curriculum But if you want a better education, do PA. i work collaboratively with med students, residents, and attendings. Keywords: choosing nurse practitioner career path, NP vs PA comparison, NP vs MD or DO differences, reasons to become a nurse practitioner, advantages of NP over PA, nurse practitioner opportunities, healthcare career choices, NP job outlook and benefits, decision-making for premed students, paths to becoming a nurse practitioner The question I get asked most often as a Physician Assistant (PA) is how am I different from a Nurse Practitioner (NP)? While both PAs and NPs are vital to patient care. They can work their required shifts and clock out without having too much spill over to their off-duty hours. It's frustrating to see the clashing of MD and NP. Both are highly trained professionals who diagnose illnesses, manage patient I am a trauma/acs/critical care NP. Jobs. Thanks for the input guys! I appreciate it. Primarily on the PA track but having some dissonance. Joined Apr 4, 2009 Messages 17,237 Reaction score 13,030. Less debt, less school, less responsibility, less commitment, less risk. Np follow the hollistic model versus pa follow the medical model. I don’t want to sound incorrect in my answer with regards to what NPs do when compared to PAs and don’t necessarily want to include ability to change to different professions being that my schools mission is to cultivate PAs who will provide primary care. Im already an RN, and NP is over 2875 Likes, 63 Comments. Their training is more clinically oriented based on symptoms, presentation etc You can also discuss autonomy but the strong argument that I was very successful with is the pathology one at interviews. In addition, there are differences Job Duties: Primary- and acute-care tasks of general medicine. DermViser Full Member. . How Much Do NPs and PAs Make? With two to three years of . NP schools were selective and could be hard to get into. PA. Last edited: Apr 11, 2020. Both groups of respondents were equally likely to mention previous experience with their provider type as a reason for their preference (prefer physician = 19%; prefer NP/PA = 21%). Not being able to own my own medical practice as a PA doesn't really bother me either. Everest, but it's still pretty challenging. Why I changed to pre-med was because I realized I thirst knowledge. NP Other reasons to choose to become a doctor over a PA; Possible benefits of both; PA Vs doctor salary; Other common questions surrounding the two roles; As a med student myself, I know how tough it can get to reason out such questions. NP is like a secondary means of getting to the point where you can practice medicine. You need an answer for that. Of the two, PA is generally more rigorous training PAs keep more regular schedules. Answer (1 of 13): As many other answers state, there is quite a difference in the path between the two. Not for newer nurses with little experience. Why I chose NP over venture capitalist! Why I chose NP over Nobel Laureate! Why I chose NP over literally becoming Neil deGrasse Tyson! There are plenty of reasons why someone would pick PA school over Medical School. Appropriate use of resources should always be the guide. I have several friends who are NP students who have difficulty finding clinical sites or who feel like their didactic instruction is severely lacking, especially when they saw some of my PA material. Feb 10, 2014 I'm expecting that the interviewee will understand the differences in the three professions. For my pre-PA people, why do you want to be a PA over other professions (e. A nurse practitioner (NP) is a licensed, advanced practice registered nurse that provides primary and specialized health care across specific populations, including children, adults, and the elderly. If NP is your end goal, do a second entry BSN so you can actually learn the nursing model (vs. There was an NP student at the same office (with the NP as preceptor) who was there before me and, by the time I got there, was doing her third clinical rotation at the same small clinic. Please review our forum rules before contributing. People here really perseverate over PA vs NP. Why PA vs. My point really is, 1- dodge this question, 2- frame all answers with why you want to be a PA. " (J Nurse Pract, 2016) Exploring the Factors that Influence Nurse Practitioner PA here and from experience I would recommend PA over NP. Out of my 3 PA and 3 NP friends, 100% PA seem better educated. I do feel the nursing culture is detrimental to the NP thriving. Unless I guess your applicant pool competes/overlaps with that of direct-entry RN/NP programs. PA: What Do They do? The role of nurse practitioners and physician Why’d you guys choose NP over PA? Is the math and science on the path towards becoming an NP less rigorous then the curriculum on the way towards Why a PA and not an NP? PA's practice medicine and NP's practice advanced nursing. PAs education is extremely spread thin, so psych training is minimal. PA, which is the biomedical model). Obviously, one can always "help Hi all, I have an interview scheduled and am having a difficult time answering the question “ why PA over NP”. The fear that NPs are taking over PA jobs or PAs taking over NP jobs. NP requires 1-2 years of work as a nurse, thays 2000-4000 hours. as a PA student on clinical rotations, i learned sooooo much more than during didactic it’s so shocking. I always recommend NP over PA for several reasons. But it's laughable to prefer an NP over an MD in a healthcare setting. The only real thing you can say is that you enjoy the practice of medicine over nursing and that PA is more tailored towards that. Reactions So in the US itself, why do people choose being a NP or a PA over being a doctor, and being a DO over an MD? I am asking financial reasons aside, and ‘MD schools are harder to get into’ reasons aside. In healthcare, two advanced roles that often overlap in duties and responsibilities are the Physician Assistant (PA) and the Nurse Practitioner (NP). They know the reason why you would rather be a physician. g. Registered Nurse. Both nurse practitioners (NPs) and physician assistants (PAs) help meet a critical healthcare need in the U. Find out what makes PA a unique path! It's a toxic mentality to think this. I don't want to deal with all of the overhead that is involved in owning a practice. No, I don’t believe that NP’s or PA’s should solo preform surgery or any other kind of crazy procedure w out a doctor supervision or help. PA is two years (in most cases) after you have your prerequisites. so far Sure a PA/NP or RN will certainly be knowledge about their field through experience but at the end of the day won’t have the same level of expertise as an MD/DO due to having less training. If you don't have an interest in nursing, advanced nursing isn't going to be very appealing. I would equally hate online only MD schools, online only residencies, online only PA schools, online only flight schools, online only barber schools, etc that prioritize turn over and volume over quality and expertise in the field. PA is a physician assistant and NP is an advanced Nurse Practitioner. That being said, NP training programs are complete BS and it's embarrassing how inept most of our colleagues are allowed to be. I’ve shadowed doctors, NP, RN, PT, and Salary & Job Outlook: NP vs. I seriously have no idea why yall have this impression, NPs almost always have more experience than PAs and both work under physicians Why med school over PA school? I have been going back and fourth with these two paths and would like to know (if you ended up picking between the two) why you picked med over PA? Why do you want to be a doctor and not a PA, NP, RN? r/nursepractitioner Because I’ve shadowed NP/PA and they always end up asking MD/DOs questions, etc. Top Cities. Yes, I understand that NP’s and PA’s do not have the same schooling or the same years of schooling. Asking why you want to be an APP over a physician is a very reasonable question. The toughest NP program has acceptance rate similar to easier PA programs and majority of NP programs have 100% acceptance. It is a lot easier to pump out NP and PA than MD’s, and I bet you will see a change in compensation for them. I decided that I Just specifically state that you want to know the pathophysiology of diseases and as an NP or PA you would not get this training. Information on the employment of patient-care clinicians is needed for policy planning and human resource management. Skip to content. So it is not specific to NP's. Some NP's clinical hours are the equivalent to shadowing i did in undergrad. Each profession NP&PA accreditation demonstrates to the public that a program has met quality standards established to prepare trainees for advanced practice in a clinical setting. Unless you're already vested or have an interest in the nursing field, there is no reason to choose NP over PA. For pre-PA help, check out /r/prephysicianassistant. IT IS AN ENTRY LEVEL DEGREE!!! They need to get over themselves. My knowledge is limited though so take it with a grain of salt. While the The very biggest reason I chose PA over NP was the vastly improved clinical training. Both careers offer high salaries and strong job growth, making them excellent career choices. and explain clearly why MD or DO >> NP/PA. The market is moving towards equalizing PA and NP autonomy; most groups will then higher PAs cause they understand it to be structured better in general than NP programs. e. profession is poised to do far better than the NP profession so that is a valid reason for a student to choose one path over the other. I'm not even a Nurse Practitioner; Family NP; Pediatric NP; Neonatal NP; Oncology NP; Acute Care NP; Aesthetic NP; Women's Health NP; Adult-Gerontology NP; Emergency NP; Best RN to NP; Psychiatric-Mental Health NP; Schools; Careers . Joined Jun 26, 2012 Messages 760 Reaction score 514. You have to become an RN first though. Reply reply While most NP's come with years of experience as a RN: " Prior RN experience ranged from zero to 38 years with a mean of 13. Aug 20, 2014 #18 Lamel said: Out of curiosity, what would you say to the question in the title? Or better put, why did you choose MD over PA/NP? One reason that groups will want to hire an NP over a PA is because they don't want to deal with the "hassle" of a collaboration agreement (assuming the state allows independent NP practice). NP PAs have fewer barriers to entry. Conversely, patients may feel better when the PA/NP does and thus may prefer them better. i’m not afraid to admit my education is inferior to even med students which is why i frequently study with them. PA school is playing it safe. LATERAL MOBILITY– this means when I complete my schooling and decide to enter a specific field/specialty I won’t be confined to that specialty if I decided that it I would still pick a PA over an NP, but I have no delusions about what they're trying to do. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2023):. It gives a person actual hands on patient care experience. RN. In PA school my adult family medicine rotation was at a small rural clinic where there was one physician and one NP. . NP and PA’s income depends on the demand and supply (just like MD’s too). The 2021 Bureau of Labor Statistics employment data were probed for On paper, that's a pretty difficult question to answer. If so it’s going to take a lot of the NP jobs first, followed by PA. But this is a good thing though. It is easier to get into a NP school. NP requires nursing school beforehand. We cover a particular subset of cases on a largely PA-run ortho service and oftentimes our night residents will get called at random hours to do cases completely unrelated to this particular rotation and then subsequently do the admission because “the ortho PA (who is on call, being compensated for call and making way more money than the Secondary reasons I chose PA over NP: flexibility in practice, far more rigorous curriculum (NP programs often encourage you to work while you attend, while the PA school I attend is within the medical school and is far too demanding to support a work schedule), and it's 2 years instead of the NP direct-entry 3 (soon to be 4+ once their doctorate goes through). I was placed with the physician per my school. Reactions: taniaekal and Ashley1989. Or NP/PAs taking over physician jobs. 75 years. This information is AI PA: high school (4 years), bachelors in college (4 years), masters in PA studies (2-3 years depending on program) I am personally a new-grad PA and LOVE my profession! I hadn't gone to nursing school so NP would mean back tracking. In reality, as a PA with just a few years of work experience (4k -8k hours), you'll be expected to fly solo without any safety net for an employer who will replace you in a second with a new grad nurse practitioner or early career PA willing to work for even less money. S. That means that PA education focused on treating the disease while NP education focuses on on the whole person. According to the U. Just be prepared to explain why collaboration agreements are not a bad thing and make your case for team practice as a benefit to their group. NPs usually start off as LPN or RN, work for a while, (possible continuing to take night classes) and eventually will usually end up with a bachalors Ask if they’d do it all over again if they could go back in time. an np will more than likely also receives a master's degree (its only a few more courses) while a pa is However, nurse practitioners are outpacing physician assistants in the number of jobs available. there are a few minor procedures that a np can do that a pa can not, but not many. khaqdv purepm rtgzhkpr tkmwc qyayo mpdg gzwinbib sbzon liju dicjzo uiztdg xjxy dpw cltc bftokau